By Brad Honywill, Communications Coordinator at CHEC
A new study from the Canadian Centre for Housing Rights (CCHR) indicates that “racialized” newcomers face a “high degree of discrimination” in accessing housing in Toronto and it makes several recommendations to help the situation.
“Every year, the Canadian Centre for Housing Rights (CCHR) receives hundreds of calls from newcomers who report experiencing discrimination and other barriers to accessing rental housing,” states the report by the non-profit housing advocacy group. “Often, newcomers tell us they can find an apartment to rent, but all too often their applications are denied based on their immigration status, racial or ethnic background, the composition of their family, or because they receive social assistance.”
To gauge the scope of discriminatory practices, CCHR conducted 1,370 paired tests that match two individuals for all relevant characteristics (e.g., income level, gender identity, marital status, etc.) with the exception of one characteristic or a combination of characteristics for which discrimination is to be assessed. Both people in the pair apply for a rental unit and their successes or failures are compared.
“As a result of carrying out the audit, we found that racialized newcomers to Toronto face a high degree of discrimination in the rental housing market,” the report states. “This was further confirmed by a survey and interviews in which newcomers shared the myriad challenges they experienced trying to access housing in Toronto’s rental sector.”
The report made the following recommendations “to prevent and address” housing discrimination:
Recommendations:
1. The Government of Canada should develop new funding streams for programs to support newcomers so that settlement organizations and other civil society groups can better address the specific challenges newcomers face in securing housing.
2. In many instances, a lack of Canadian credit history or guarantor are the basis upon which housing providers deny housing to newcomers. Knowing this, the Government of Ontario and the Government of Canada should establish no-fee guarantor services to support newcomers to access housing upon arrival in Canada.
3. Initiatives to investigate the nature, scope, and impact of discriminatory housing practices against newcomers and other equity-deserving groups should be funded and undertaken across Ontario.
4. The Government of Ontario should provide funding for studies, and the Ontario Human Rights Commission should work with housing organizations and advocates to further investigate these barriers and develop realistic and relevant solutions to ensure people have access to the housing they need.
5. The Government of Ontario should establish a system for monitoring, investigating, and meaningfully enforcing Human Rights Code protections related to housing.
6. The Government of Ontario should implement policies to preserve existing affordable housing stock that is at risk of being lost. These policies should include permitting localized rental replacement bylaws, and financing for municipal acquisition programs that convert at-risk privately owned affordable rental housing into non-profit housing.
7. The Government of Ontario should work collaboratively with municipalities to encourage the development of non-profit and co-operative housing in order to provide more affordable housing options for lower-income households.
8. The Government of Ontario and the City of Toronto should further develop, encourage, and promote education for tenants to learn about their legal rights and for housing providers to learn about their legal obligations.
9. Multi-tenant (rooming) houses provide a deeply affordable housing option for newcomers who live on lower incomes. The City of Toronto should adopt a regulatory framework for multi-tenant houses that allows for the legal operation of this type of housing across the city.
Full report can be accessed here: CCHR-Sorry-its-rented-Discrimination-Audit-2022.pdf (housingrightscanada.com)